Forum Discussion

tahadev0387's avatar
tahadev0387
Level 1.5: Cupcake
2 months ago

Clarification on Google Workspace Context-Aware Access vs Chrome Enterprise Premium Context-Aware Access

Hi everyone,

 

I’m hoping to get some clarification on the differences between Google Workspace Context-Aware Access (CAA) and Chrome Enterprise Premium Context-Aware Access.

 

From what I understand, both allow conditional access controls based on user, device, and context, but I’m not fully clear on where the separation lies between them. For example:

  • Does Workspace CAA mainly govern access to Google Workspace apps like Gmail and Drive, while Chrome Enterprise Premium CAA extends those controls to managed browsers and web apps?
  • How do policy management and enforcement differ between the two?
  • Are there separate admin configurations, or do they integrate within the same console?

I also noticed that Context-Aware Access now supports OIDC, and that CAA for OIDC apps can be configured at the OU level. Does this capability apply to both Workspace and Chrome Enterprise CAA, or is it specific to one of them?

If anyone has experience managing both solutions — or can share any official documentation that clarifies the distinctions — I’d really appreciate your insights.

Thanks in advance,

chrome enterprise premium

1 Reply

  • Lynda's avatar
    Lynda
    Google Community Manager
    2 months ago

    Hi tahadev0387​ , great to have you in the community and thanks for the question.

     

    This is a long response, apologies in advance but we do hope it helps.

     

    I'd also ask any of our members who are managing their organisations through both products to share their experience and the practical management and nuances in the day to day running of an organisation?

     

    The distinction between Google Workspace Context-Aware Access (CAA) and Chrome Enterprise Premium Context-Aware Access is primarily about the scope of what is being protected and the richness of the access signals available.

     

    Here is a breakdown to clarify the differences based on the current offerings:

     

    FeatureGoogle Workspace Context-Aware Access (CAA)Chrome Enterprise Premium Context-Aware Access (CAA)
    Primary ScopeGoogle Workspace apps (Gmail, Drive, Meet, etc.)Managed Browsers and Web Apps (SaaS apps, Google Cloud resources, private web apps and thick client apps through Cameyo) - Brings Application Access Control, DLP, Threat Mitigation and deep telemetry (SIEM/SOAR) to managed and unmanaged devices alike.
    Enforcement PointEnforced when accessing a Workspace app.Extends enforcement to the managed Chrome browser/profile and via Identity-Aware Proxy (IAP) for other apps.
    Access SignalsBasic signals: User identity, IP/Geographic location, Device type, basic OS status (via Endpoint Verification).Expanded, richer device/browser signals from Chrome and third-party partners (e.g., CrowdStrike, Tanium) including: Deeper device security posture, advanced DLP (Data Loss Prevention) controls, risk scores, session management.
    Data Loss Prevention (DLP)Primarily applies to Workspace data (Drive, Gmail).Enhanced DLP for corporate data in the browser, including such controls for copy/paste, print, and file downloads/uploads, screenshot prevention, data obfuscation, watermarking and much more on any application running in the browser.
    LicensingIncluded with higher-tier Workspace editions (e.g., Enterprise Plus) and Cloud Identity Premium.Requires a Chrome Enterprise Premium license.

     

    Scope of protection

     

    • Workspace CAA essentially governs who gets access to the Google Workspace productivity suite. It uses your identity and basic context to either grant or block access to services like Gmail, Drive, and Google Docs.
    • Chrome Enterprise Premium CAA extends those controls beyond the core Workspace apps.It applies context-aware policies to:
      • Managed browser sessions: Enforcing security policies (like DLP/Real time phishing or Malware detection) to the browser session itself, regardless of the web app being visited.
      • SaaS/Third-Party Web Apps: Applying conditional access to 1st party and non-Google apps, often integrating with tools like Identity-Aware Proxy (IAP) for Google Cloud resources.
      • Unmanaged Devices/Extended Workforce/BYOD Protection: Consistent policies to the distributed or BYOD workforce mean all users accessing corporate data are protected and secured via the same security measures you would apply on Managed Devices.

     

    Policy management and enforcement

     

    • CAA Access Levels are fundamentally the same core engine (Access Context Manager). You create the same kind of access levels (e.g., "Device is encrypted and location is in North America").
    • The Difference is the Attribute Detail:
      • Workspace CAA relies heavily on information gathered by Endpoint Verification (part of the Google Admin console), which provides device-level data (OS version, screen lock, encryption status).
      • Chrome Enterprise Premium CAA leverages Chrome Enterprise Core to get much richer, browser-specific signals and integrates with a wider array of CEP (BeyondCorp) Alliance partners (like CrowdStrike or Palo Alto) to incorporate their real-time device posture/risk scores into the access decision.

     

    Admin configuration

     

    • Integration: The Access Levels themselves (the conditions) are managed in a shared resource space that is accessible through the Google Admin Console.
    • Application of Policies:
      • Workspace CAA policies are assigned to specific Google Workspace Apps (like Drive, Gmail) within the Google Admin Console.
      • Chrome Enterprise Premium CAA policies are used to enforce browser-based controls (DLP, URL filtering) via Chrome Browser Cloud Management and to gate access to Google Cloud resources via Identity-Aware Proxy (IAP).

     

    Open ID Connect (OIDC) support

     

    • The capability to apply Context-Aware Access to apps using OpenID Connect (OIDC) and to configure this at the OU level is a feature primarily associated with Google Workspace/Cloud Identity Premium.
    • This feature allows you to extend the access policies you've defined to third-party apps that use Google Sign-In as their Identity Provider (IdP).
    • Since Workspace CAA and Cloud Identity Premium are the foundation for managing identity within the Google ecosystem, this OIDC capability applies to the access policies created within that framework. The access levels themselves can be leveraged by both Workspace and Chrome Enterprise Premium components, but the feature to apply CAA to the set of OIDC apps is a core Workspace/Cloud Identity function.

     

    Essentially, Workspace CAA is the gatekeeper for your core productivity tools, while Chrome Enterprise Premium CAA is the gatekeeper for your managed browser environment, providing richer device context and broader app coverage (SaaS, internal web apps).

     

    To find out more about both products and their nuances check out:

     

    Again I want to ask our Community member base who are managing their organisations through both products to share their experience and the practical management and nuances in the day to day running of an organisation. Comment below!